top of page

Gaslighting of Nevada HOA Reform: Attorney Fees First, Homeowner Protections TBD

Writer: Mike Kosor
Mike Kosor
1 day ago
7 min read

Updated: 6 hours ago

Is denying homeowners reasonable access to an independent, written determination of their rights an unintended consequence—or part of the objective?


Homeowners need an affordable way to determine their rights when they and their association have a dispute. Usually, they are asking a simple question: Are my association officials following the law, our governing documents, and respecting my rights?


But our civil litigation system is ill-suited to most HOA disputes. They are not typically about substantial money damages. They concern process, elections, access to records, or the interpretation of laws and governing documents—whether a rule was followed, a notice properly given, or a required procedure observed.


Add prevailing-party attorney-fee provisions, found in many HOA governing documents and Nevada's HOA statutes, and obtaining that answer or enforcing an owner's rights through litigation is rarely economically rational. This reality is not lost on association officials defending against an owner's challenge, spending homeowners' assessments—not their own money—or on association counsel for whom litigation is a lucrative business, win or lose. Read more: Putting Owners First: A New Framework for HOA Dispute Resolution.


After decades of reform, Nevada homeowners still face financial barriers to enforcing their rights. The referee program offers another path—but only if both parties agree to use it.
After decades of reform, Nevada homeowners still face financial barriers to enforcing their rights. The referee program offers another path—but only if both parties agree to use it.

In 1995, Nevada lawmakers required many disputes involving HOA governing documents to undergo mediation or arbitration before proceeding to court—a process known as alternative dispute resolution (ADR). But arbitration could be costly, and homeowners risked paying the association's attorney fees if they lost. Even winning offered no assurance of finality. An association could take the dispute to court, exposing the homeowner to the very financial risks they sought to avoid. Lawmakers would repeatedly revisit the process in search of a solution.


In 2013, NRED proposed a Referee Program that prohibited attorney-fee awards, limited monetary awards to $7,500, and offered hearings and decisions at no cost to the parties other than a nominal filing fee. The Administrator explained:


The impetus for this change in the law is to address the overwhelming cost of arbitrations that discourages homeowners from asserting their rights. The referee will be able to look at the issues and provide a decision upon which the homeowner can assess their likelihood of success in court. The process would be streamlined and consist of a hearing before the referee, unless the parties agreed not to have a hearing. The Division believes this process would satisfy a significant need of Nevada homeowners living in common-interest communities.


It was indeed what homeowners need- but could they use it?


Three Decades of Excuses. The Same Result.

The legislative history is remarkably revealing. Homeowners sought something straightforward: an independent determination of their rights. Even if nonbinding, a written assessment of the merits would leave a homeowner better informed before entering litigation and assuming the financial risks that accompany it.


Sounds reasonable. Even straightforward.


Attorneys however, often as lobbyist and representing deep-pocketed interests, have long dominated the conversation in the halls of Carson City. They challenged the NRED 2013 initiative in AB 370 to provide meaningful ADR alternatives.


In the end, lawmakers enacted AB 370 and established the Referee Program. But the legislative "compromise" reversed the default. Mediation replaced arbitration, and homeowners could obtain a referee's independent determination only if their association agreed. Arbitration remained available by mutual agreement after unsuccessful mediation or referee review.


Mediation may produce a settlement, but it does not provide an independent written determination of whether the association complied with the law or respected the homeowner's rights. If mediation fails, the homeowner faces the same choice: abandon the dispute or risk expensive litigation.


Consider the arguments presented in the May 8, 2013 opposition to AB 370, opposing the Referee Program. Keep in mind who advanced these arguments: the Common-Interest Committee of the State Bar's Real Property Section. The State Bar of Nevada is a public corporation under the Nevada Supreme Court's jurisdiction, charged with improving the administration of justice and promoting legal reform.


Were these attorneys defending the existing litigation system because they believed its financial deterrents served the broader public interest—or because they wanted to preserve attorney fees, regardless their effect?


Attorney fees discourage frivolous claims. True. And in ordinary civil litigation, they have a place. But HOA disputes are not ordinary. The objective is to keep them from becoming litigation. Whether a claim is frivolous should be determined by its merits—not by the price a homeowner must pay to have it heard. More importantly, this objection ignores why expensive litigation should be necessary in the first place. Homeowners generally want little more than an independent determination of what the law and governing documents, written by a developer and absent any regulatory approval, require—not a Supreme Court ruling. That should not require risking their life savings or their home.


The existing ADR system works. Really? Not what history tells us. And where are the performance statistics demonstrating that disputes were actually being resolved? Nevada's own regulators now acknowledge that voluntary dispute resolution frequently fails to deliver results.


Calling a system successful for decades does not make it so.


An unspecified program. That was the attorneys' opening objection. Hollow. The program's purpose and basic procedures were clear. What they called "unaddressed" were largely the elaborate procedures of arbitration—discovery, subpoenas, depositions, and formal award requirements. But avoiding much of that costly machinery was precisely the point of offering a simpler referee process. They even objected that referees "may not award attorney's fees." A simplified hearing is not necessarily unfair, and the absence of attorney-fee awards is not a denial of due process. Was the objection really about protecting homeowners' rights—or preserving the costly process the reform was intended to avoid?


The program raises serious due-process concerns. The attorneys cited alleged deficiencies in the pilot program, even pointing to a lawsuit that produced no judicial ruling establishing those allegations. Due process requires fair notice, an opportunity to be heard, and an impartial determination. Those protections can—and should—be provided without requiring attorney-fee awards, which the attorneys seem determined to associate with elaborate legal proceedings. Without an affordable means of obtaining a decision, alternative dispute resolution (ADR) becomes little more than a speed bump on the way to costly litigation—where the threat of attorney fees remains the hammer.


Affordable adjudication will encourage more claims. Or perhaps it reveals how many legitimate complaints have been suppressed by the cost of pursuing them. Since when is making justice affordable a problem that needs preventing?


The referee program lacks procedural safeguards. Notice, an opportunity to be heard, impartiality, and a written determination are fundamental safeguards the program was intended to provide. If more protections are needed, establish them. Fair notice does not require attorney-fee awards. Don't use a correctable administrative concern to resist a program designed to spare homeowners the expense and threat of attorney-fee awards.

State-appointed referees might not be impartial. “Might”? Based on what evidence? Nevada already entrusts appointed officials with consequential administrative decisions. Establish qualifications and safeguards against bias. Hyperbolic speculation is not a reason to deny affordable adjudication.


The program lacks statutory authority. Finally, a valid objection. And precisely why lawmakers were being asked to provide that authority. A reason to enact legislation, not abandon the solution.


What Did the "Compromise" Actually Deliver?

Lawmakers established the affordable referee program—but gave the association being challenged the power to prevent its use. Think about that. A homeowner could seek an independent determination of what the governing documents require, but the association could simply refuse.


And lawmakers had been warned. In their opposition testimony noted above the attorneys themselves acknowledged that "mediation is not applicable to many disputes." Yet the legislative "compromise" made mediation the default—the very process the attorneys acknowledged was unsuitable for many disputes—while allowing associations to refuse the referee alternative.


Who benefited from that "compromise"? Whose interests were being protected?


Homeowners see through this facade. And it is difficult to believe lawmakers cannot. That makes what has transpired over three decades all the harder to reconcile. Lawmakers repeatedly recognize the need for affordable justice, yet the resulting compromises preserve the very financial leverage reform was supposed to address.


We euphemistically call it "politics." But when does "politics" stop being an acceptable explanation for repeatedly sacrificing homeowner protections?


Look past the arguments. What survived? Prevailing-party attorney fees.


The old adage follow the money holds considerable wisdom.


Now the Regulators Acknowledge the Problem

Thirteen years later, Nevada's CIC Task Force has heard what homeowner advocates have been saying all along. NRED once again acknowledges that voluntary participation in the existing ADR process frequently fails to resolve disputes. Yet lawmakers have already created a solution—the Referee Program.


Remove the association's veto. Make referee adjudication the default, without exposing either party to prevailing-party attorney-fee awards. Give homeowners—and associations that genuinely seek to do what is right for their members—an independent determination of their rights before deciding whether litigation is worth the financial risk.


That is the reform NRED sought in 2013—and the compromise lawmakers should have delivered.


Don't Let Another Compromise Become Law

As Nevada approaches the 2027 legislative session, expect to see the CIC Task Force's proposed changes to ADR. They deserve close scrutiny.


If lawmakers enact the proposed return to nonbinding arbitration with prevailing-party attorney-fee awards, Nevada will have come full circle.


Back to arbitration. Back to attorney-fee awards. Back to the very financial risks NRED sought to address in 2013.


Thirty-one years after Nevada first established mandatory ADR, homeowners could again face the same fundamental question: Is obtaining an independent determination of my rights worth the financial risk?


All of us—especially the lawmakers to whom we entrust the power to protect our rights—must remain vigilant. A system designed to deter frivolous claims can just as easily deter legitimate ones. And after decades of resistance to affordable alternatives, we must confront an uncomfortable question: What if deterring legitimate homeowner challenges—and denying reasonable access to an independent, written determination of their rights—is not an unintended consequence, but part of the objective?


No more excuses. No more compromises that preserve the financial hammer. Make referee adjudication the default.


Nevada homeowners deserve protections they can actually enforce—not another façade of reform.



bottom of page