Is Your HOA in Litigation?

Summary: Why This Matters
Nevada law generally requires homeowner approval before an association initiates litigation. That is a high bar—by design. But broad exceptions can swallow that rule, allowing boards to commit substantial association resources, potentially even using litigation to intimidate opposition, without an owner vote or meaningful homeowner knowledge.
Although boards must review the status of pending litigation at least quarterly, existing requirements do not clearly ensure homeowners receive meaningful information about the cases, their expenses, or the financial risks involved. Nor do they expressly require a separate public vote identifying which directors authorized litigation under an exception to homeowner approval or explaining why that exception was justified.
NRED and the CIC Commission should address these deficiencies through regulatory action or, where necessary, recommended legislation.
Homeowners should not have to search courthouse records or wait for a special assessment to discover that their association is involved in costly litigation.
For readers interested in the statutory requirements, legislative history, regulatory guidance, and documented examples supporting our recommendations, the following sections explain why we believe reform is warranted.
Introduction
Your homeowners association could be involved in costly litigation, exposing you and your neighbors to substantial financial obligations and you might know nothing about it until the bill comes due. There is much about this that deserves examination—and change.
Civil proceedings can continue for years, accumulating substantial legal expenses and potentially exposing the association to adverse judgments. Those costs can reach homeowners through increased assessments, special assessments, or depleted association resources—particularly when insurance coverage is unavailable, disputed, or insufficient.
Nevada law generally requires homeowner approval before an HOA initiates litigation. That is a high bar—by design. But broad exceptions, subject to expansive interpretation, permit associations to pursue litigation without an owner vote. And when lawmakers dispense with the safeguard of homeowner approval, public accountability becomes more important, not less.
Consider an HOA sued by a homeowner alleging improper actions involving a board election. The board, acting on behalf of the association, may defend the lawsuit and assert a counterclaim against the homeowner increasing the financial stakes. Nevada law does not require homeowner approval for the counterclaim. Nor does it expressly require the association to notify homeowners of when litigation begins, explain the allegations, justify any counterclaim, or disclose potential costs and financial risks.

Yes, NRS 116.31083(7)(f) requires HOA boards to review pending litigation and some claims. But requiring a board to "review the current status of any civil action or claim submitted to arbitration or mediation" at a board meeting at least every 100 days does not necessarily ensure homeowners are meaningfully informed. As we illustrate later, some associations appear to interpret this review obligation as requiring very little meaningful disclosure.
Legal expenses may appear in association financial statements, but those figures do not necessarily identify the litigation, explain its purpose, or distinguish litigation expenses from other legal costs. Nor do ordinary financial statements necessarily reveal anticipated expenses or potential liabilities. Audited statements may disclose certain material litigation contingencies, but Nevada law does not generally require associations to distribute completed audit reports to every existing homeowner.
And let's be real. If you live in an HOA, when was the last time you read your association's financial statements, much less its audit report?
There is also the question of accountability. Decisions may follow confidential discussions with association counsel, leaving homeowners unaware of why the board chose to litigate, expand an action, or which directors supported the action. Requiring an open board vote before invoking a statutory exception would not itself prevent abuse, but it would expose the decision, its justification, and the directors responsible to homeowner scrutiny. Privileged legal advice would remain protected.
What Needs to Change
Important considerations are at play in designing disclosure requirements. Reform need not give homeowners authority to approve every lawsuit in all cases or require disclosure of privileged communications. It should, however, ensure homeowners receive meaningful information about litigation involving their association, including lawsuits exempt from homeowner approval.
Without clear, affirmative disclosure requirements, a board may satisfy its existing legal obligations while providing homeowners little information about lawsuits initiated in their association's name, the costs being incurred, or the financial risks they may ultimately bear. Homeowners should not have to depend on a board's willingness to share information about litigation they are required to finance.
Two protections are essential.
First, prompt notice. Associations should be required to notify homeowners when they initiate litigation or become a party to a lawsuit, regardless of whether homeowner approval is required. Disclosure at the next public board meeting, appropriately identified and recorded in the minutes, may be sufficient. But the key here is appropriately identified. In anddtion, when the board invokes an exception to homeowner approval, the decision should ordinarily require a public board vote before litigation begins, identifying the exception and the directors supporting it.
Second, periodic updates. NRS 116.31083 already requires boards to review pending litigation at least quarterly. Regulations (or legislation if needed) should ensure the review contain a meaningful, nonprivileged report to homeowners identifying material developments, litigation expenses, and reasonably ascertainable financial risks. Where potential exposure cannot reasonably be estimated, the association should say so rather than speculate. Attorney-client privilege and legitimate confidentiality protections would remain intact.
I challenge claims that have been raised in the past, these requirements would be excessively burdensome. Directors already must review litigation quarterly. Besides, if simply informing homeowners and periodically updating them about litigation involving their association is considered burdensome, perhaps a closer examination of the association's use of litigation is warranted.
The Evidence Behind Our Recommendations
NRS 116.31088 — Homeowner approval of HOA lawsuits. Nevada law generally requires associations to obtain approval from homeowners holding a majority of all allocated votes before initiating civil litigation. Exceptions are collecting assessments, enforcing the declaration, bylaws or rules, enforcing vendor contracts, pursuing counterclaims, and litigation involving members' health, safety and welfare (HSW). The HSW exception includes a requirement for subsequent homeowner ratification within 90 days- but interestingly it is the only excepting that does.
NRS 116.31083(7)(f) — Quarterly review. The executive board must review the current status of civil actions and claims submitted to arbitration or mediation in which the association is a party.
NRS 116.31175 — Records access. Homeowners may inspect association records, including court filings involving the association. But owners must seek those records themselves. The statute does not require periodic litigation reports.
NRS 116.31088(4) — Settlements. The board must disclose the terms and conditions of a settled civil action at its next regularly scheduled meeting. But this occurs after the settlement has been reached, and the statute provides little detail about the form or completeness of the disclosure.
Note: It is possible that an association's governing documents impose additional disclosure requirements, although it is my assessment that this is uncommon.
When Exceptions Threaten to Swallow the Rule
At first glance, NRS 116.31088 appears to provide a reasonable balance between homeowner protection and the board's authority to govern association operations. Before committing the association to civil litigation, the board generally must obtain approval from homeowners holding a majority of all allocated votes.
However, owner vote requirement presents legitimate practical challenges. In a large community, obtaining approval from a majority of all homeowner votes—not merely those cast—can be expensive, time-consuming, and difficult. So lawmakers provided exceptions for arguably legitimate association needs. But those exceptions can undermine the homeowner protection the approval requirement was designed to provide.
On examination, several exceptions do just that. They are broad enough to drive a truck—or, in this case, an HOA—through.

First example, boards already have substantial statutory enforcement powers, including the authority to impose recurring fines for continuing violations. There may be circumstances when fines prove inadequate and litigation is justified. But there is no explicit statutory requirement that directors demonstrate, either before initiating litigation or afterward, that existing enforcement remedies were inadequate or that litigation was necessary.
Consider an architectural violation that poses no health, safety, or welfare threat. Under the governing-document enforcement exception, the board can initiate litigation without homeowner approval, even when the association has other enforcement remedies available. The homeowner facing the lawsuit could incur substantial legal expenses defending against a relatively minor violation, while the association's membership finances the litigation. And the law does not expressly require directors to demonstrate to homeowners, before initiating litigation or afterward, why existing enforcement remedies were inadequate or litigation was necessary. That decision warrants public scrutiny.
The counterclaim exception presents a similar concern. Returning to our earlier example, a homeowner sues the association alleging improper actions by its board. The board responds with a counterclaim, expanding the litigation and its potential costs—to both the association and the homeowner. What would other homeowners actually know about that decision? A counterclaim may be necessary to preserve a legitimate association claim, or it may be an unnecessary expansion of litigation having little to nothing to do with the original action. How would homeowners know which?
Regardless, the potential for abuse must be recognized. That concern is in large part why lawmakers generally require homeowner approval before associations initiate litigation. Even if the counterclaim is ultimately dismissed, the homeowner may have incurred substantial legal expenses defending against it. The prospect of those expenses may appropriately discourage frivolous litigation. But it can also be exploited to intimidate homeowners pursuing legitimate claims, even when the counterclaim itself has little merit. And the consequences may extend beyond the immediate dispute: other homeowners, witnessing the financial risks of challenging their association, may be discouraged from asserting legitimate rights of their own.
An open board vote could expose that decision to homeowner scrutiny, including whether the counterclaim was necessary and which directors supported it. That transparency could discourage both the use of counterclaims to intimidate homeowners and the heavy-handed exercise of litigation authority for board so inclined.
The health, safety and welfare (HSW) exception raises yet another concern. Without clear statutory criteria governing using the HSW label, boards have extraordinary latitude to characterize litigation as involving members' welfare. Many associations have already experinced how broadly and damaging this justification can be applied. Lawmakers clearly intended to limit board discretion when it comes to litigation. But with regulators recently approving an expansive interpretation of what constitutes HSW, this exception may accomplish precisely the opposite.
Requiring directors to publicly identify the exceptions they invoke would expose their decisions to homeowner scrutiny. That alone would not establish whether those decisions were legally justified—or whether the exceptions themselves are being interpreted and applied as lawmakers intended. More is needed.
This is not a hypothetical concern. Actual litigation and legal interpretations advanced by association counsel demonstrate that these exceptions have been interpreted and applied in ways that can substantially diminish the homeowner protections lawmakers established.
We examine these concerns and their implications in a follow-up post. Nevada's HOA Litigation Protections: How Did We Lose Sight of the Original Purpose? (Coming soon.)
Nevada's regulators and lawmakers must revisit these protections, clarify the scope of the exceptions, and address the consequences when statutory approval or ratification requirements are not satisfied.
What Does a Quarterly Litigation Review Tell Homeowners?
Nevada law requires boards to "review" pending litigation at least quarterly. But what does that mean for homeowners who want to know how their association's resources are being used? Potentially little. Consider the following entry from the board meeting minutes of one large Nevada HOA:
LITIGATION UPDATE: [Ms. Attorney] provided the Board with legal updates.
That is the entire entry. It identifies no lawsuits, describes no developments, and provides no information about litigation expenses or potential financial exposure. In this case there were at least two and possible three actions ongoing in this HOA. Whatever information directors may have received, the minutes tell homeowners virtually nothing.
The statutory language itself leaves room for restrictive interpretations. NRS 116.31083(7) requires directors to review certain "financial information," including the "current status" of litigation involving the association. Because litigation is included within a financial-review requirement, boards could interpret their obligation narrowly, focusing on financial consequences rather than the nature, purpose, or progress of the litigation.
Nor does the requirement that meeting minutes reflect the "substance" of matters discussed necessarily solve the problem. If little is discussed publicly, little may be recorded. And without clear standards defining what constitutes meaningful disclosure, even the adequacy of the minutes can become a matter of legal dispute.
The irony should not be overlooked: Homeowners could find themselves having to pursue legal or regulaotry action simply to obtain meaningful information about litigation their association is already financing. Clear regulatory disclosure standards could help prevent that outcome.

Buyers Must Be Told. Why Not Existing Homeowners?
Nevada lawmakers recognized decades ago that pending HOA litigation is important information for someone considering purchasing a home in a common-interest community. When Nevada adopted the Uniform Common-Interest Ownership Act in 1991, it required developers to disclose certain pending lawsuits in public offering statements. In 1997, lawmakers amended the resale requirements to include judgments and pending legal actions involving the association.
Today, NRS 116.4109 requires resale packages to include information about unsatisfied judgments, pending legal actions against the association, and the status of certain other pending litigation affecting the community. Yet existing homeowners have no comparable general right to be affirmatively notified. The 2019 legislative record suggests lawmakers may have been misinformed about what Nevada law already required.
Lawmakers Were Told Homeowners Were Already Protected
The Legislature had an opportunity to consider this problem in 2019, more than two decades after lawmakers first required litigation disclosures to prospective resale purchasers. Instead, it narrowed an existing litigation-disclosure requirement after receiving assurances that homeowners were already adequately informed through other provisions of Nevada law. Those assurances had a statutory foundation, but overlooked a loophole that could leave homeowners financing litigation without meaningful information about it.
During the April 5, 2019 Senate Judiciary Committee hearing on SB 382, the Community Associations Institute (CAI) proposed an amendment limiting written litigation cost-and-risk disclosures to lawsuits requiring homeowner approval. CAI justified the amendment as a cost-saving measure, arguing that requiring written disclosures for litigation exempt from homeowner approval would impose an unnecessary burden without providing a discernible benefit. When questioned about the frequency and burden of such litigation, its representative acknowledged having no exact statistics. Nor was a quantified estimate of the disclosure costs provided.
The reasoning presented was circular. Because homeowners had no vote, CAI argued they had no need for the disclosure. Yet denying homeowners a vote does not eliminate their financial interest in the litigation—or their need to know what risks their association is undertaking.
A senator questioned why homeowners should lose access to litigation information simply because they were not entitled to vote on whether the litigation proceeded. The attorney representing CAI, who had long been involved in Nevada HOA legislation, responded that existing law already provided mechanisms for owners to be fully informed about litigation, even without voting rights. The CAI representative specifically asserted:
"The HOA is required under Nevada law to give the owners a summary of pending litigation at regular board meetings, which are required to occur at least quarterly."
The statement deserves closer examination. As previously noted, NRS 116.31083(7)(f) requires the board to review litigation status at least quarterly. And, as NRED subsequently explained in 2021, that review belongs at a regular board meeting. Most directors—and reasonably, the lawmakers hearing this testimony—might understand that requirement to mean homeowners would receive meaningful information about pending litigation. But the law does not clearly say so. It requires a review without prescribing what homeowners must actually be told. A board seeking to minimize scrutiny of its litigation activity, particularly lawsuits intended to defend or preserve its authority, could exploit that distinction while maintaining that it complied with the law.
The statute does not expressly require a quarterly summary identifying each lawsuit, its status, accumulated legal expenses, or potential financial consequences. It also requires meeting minutes to include the substance of matters discussed, subject to reasonable limitations, without defining what an adequate litigation-status report must contain.
The CAI representative offered two additional assurances: pending litigation is disclosed during property resales, and homeowners have statutory rights to inspect association records. Both provisions exist. But neither provides the affirmative, continuing disclosure that the senator was questioning.
Resale disclosures are provided during a property transaction—not periodically to existing homeowners. Records-access rights require owners to seek information, much of which may already be publicly available through court filings. Meanwhile, associations may assert attorney-client privilege over legal assessments and other communications.
The right to know and the right to approve litigation are separate issues.
Nevertheless, the Legislature adopted the amendment narrowing the written litigation-disclosure requirement. Lawmakers had been assured that homeowners already received quarterly litigation summaries, but the statute did not clearly require the substantive disclosure those assurances implied. The result was not simply a reduction in paperwork. It was the loss of an affirmative disclosure protection without ensuring that another requirement would provide equivalent information.
A board acting responsibly may provide homeowners with meaningful litigation updates. But disclosure requirements are especially important when a board is reluctant to disclose its actions—not merely when a board is already committed to transparency. A board seeking to conceal its litigious practices, or avoid scrutiny of litigation undertaken to protect its own authority, can exploit the absence of a clear disclosure standard. The law should protect homeowners regardless of which kind of board governs their association.
Protecting Legal Strategy Does Not Require Keeping Homeowners Uninformed
An argument often raised against litigation disclosures is the need to protect confidential attorney-client communications and avoid compromising an association's legal position.
That concern is legitimate. But it does not justify treating all litigation information as confidential.
There is an established model for distinguishing the two. Federal securities laws require publicly traded corporations to disclose material pending litigation and certain financial risks to investors. Under Securities and Exchange Commission reporting requirements, companies may have to identify significant legal proceedings, describe their nature, and disclose material financial uncertainties. Those obligations generally do not require disclosure of privileged legal advice, confidential litigation strategies, or private settlement positions.
Nevada HOAs are not publicly traded corporations, and SEC reporting rules do not govern their ordinary operations. But the underlying distinction is useful. Investors can receive meaningful information about litigation risk without receiving privileged legal advice.
Homeowners can be informed under the same general principle. Owners should be told that their association has been sued, the nature of the claim, its current status, how much the association has spent, and whether the proceedings present a material financial risk. It can help homeowners understand how their directors exercise their authority and enforce—or fail to enforce—the law and governing documents. Many associations may already provide such information voluntarily. The problem is that Nevada law does not generally require it.
Confidentiality should protect privileged legal information. It should not serve as a blanket justification for withholding basic information about litigation and its financial consequences.
Where Is Our Regulator?
In its Spring 2014 Community Insights newsletter, page 7, NRED was asked whether an HOA board must notify homeowners when the association is sued. The Division acknowledged that NRS 116 contained no specific notification requirement. But it explained that directors' fiduciary duties under NRS 116.3103 obligated them to inform homeowners of potential liabilities and unbudgeted expenses arising from litigation. It suggested placing the matter on the board meeting agenda.
That acknowledgment came five years before the 2019 legislation narrowed the written litigation-disclosure requirement. Yet when lawmakers considered that change, they were assured that other statutory provisions already kept homeowners informed.
The Coalition also examined whether NRED or the CIC Commission subsequently acted to reconcile this acknowledged fiduciary obligation with the absence of a clear, enforceable standard for reporting litigation to homeowners. We found no evidence that either regulator addressed the problem through rulemaking, formal guidance, or recommendations for legislative correction.
The problem may not be a shortage of laws. NRED itself recognized a duty to inform homeowners more than a decade ago. The unanswered question is why that duty has never been translated into clear, meaningful disclosure requirements that homeowners can rely upon.
This post identifies several potential ambiguities in existing law and opportunities for abuse. NRED and the Commission should examine these concerns, clarify the applicable requirements, and adopt regulations where necessary. If regulators conclude their authority is insufficient, they should identify the statutory limitations and recommend the necessary legislative amendments.
Homeowners should not have to search courthouse records, demand association documents, or wait for a special assessment to discover that their association is involved in costly litigation.


