top of page

Declarant Control- a little known dark secret #1

Writer: Mike Kosor
Mike Kosor
Apr 20, 2025
3 min read

Updated: 6 days ago

Most homeowners are completely unaware of how Declarant Control (i.e. developer control) of an HOA works or how long a developer will retain the ability to appoint the majority of directors- arguably all directors (see NRS 116.31032)- responsible for governing an HOA.


Nevada (as with most states) does not require pre-sale disclosure of the communities' control status. Buyers have no idea when, if ever, their community governance will be democratic. If you own a unit in a community where a developer has not relinquished "control", the board is not required and likely does not provide owners an estimate as to when the developer control could terminate. 

​

The untold secret is developer control can effectively be indefinite. The control termination threshold is calculated by dividing units conveyed to other than a declarant and annexed into the HOA by the maximum units allowed. The maximum units should be set in the CC&Rs- a document written by the developer. Developers can set most any maximum unit number it wishes. And/or, the "statement" required by law (NRS 116.2105(1)(d)) makes it almost impossible to definitive establish where control terminates.

 

There is no regulatory oversight or statutory requirement a developer actually be able to provide the units he/she establishes as the maximum units in the CC&Rs. As such, developers can make "conservative" [overstate] maximum unit projections. Doing so in turn can significantly delay reaching the termination threshold and "could effectively mean that the association might never transition"-even at build out. (NRED Administrator, Nevada Senate Committee on Judiciary hearing on AB370(2013), May 30, 2013)     

​

Our Nevada regulators do not track the declarant control threshold. Nor do they require owners be given the threshold numbers. The "system" relies solely on the association's unelected board acting appropriately when the developer termination threshold is reached.  

​

The 2015 Complication

In 2015, the Nevada Legislature enacted AB 192, Chapter 172, which amended NRS 116.31032 to extend the statutory maximum period of declarant control for common-interest communities containing 1,000 or more units.


Before AB 192, declarant control was required to terminate no later than 60 days after 75% of the units that could be created had been conveyed to owners other than the declarant. AB 192 increased that statutory threshold to 90% for communities with 1,000 or more units, while retaining the 75% threshold for smaller communities.


Importantly, AB 192 did not expressly eliminate or override an earlier turnover threshold established in an association's recorded CC&Rs. NRS 116.31032 continues to provide that the declaration may establish the period of declarant control, subject to the statute's mandatory termination limits. In my view, the statutory 90% threshold is therefore an outside limit for qualifying larger communities, not an automatic extension of declarant control where the declaration requires earlier turnover.


Had the legislators intended to impact/change existing CC&Rs they would have removed the above language in 2015. Review of the legislative history finds no intent legislators wanted to change existing contracts/CC&Rs. Doing so would bring into play the Contract Clause of the US Constitution.  

 

Some HOA attorneys disagree with this interpretation, contending that the 2015 amendment permits declarants of qualifying larger communities to retain control until the 90% threshold is reached, notwithstanding an earlier threshold in the declaration. The disagreement concerns the legal effect of AB 192 on existing governing documents, not whether the Legislature increased the statutory threshold.


What the legislature intended (and enacted for what I see as flawed reasons) was the ability of developers to contract with HOA owners (CC&Rs) for a longer period of control. Prior to the 2015 change a contract for greater than 75% would have violated NRS on its face and be unenforceable. Developers writing new CC&Rs after 2015 now routinely contract for 90%.


The fact this consequential disagreement over the meaning of Nevada law remains unresolved through the state's regulatory process is also concerning. Owners and associations are left to rely on competing interpretations, potentially requiring costly litigation to establish when declarant control must end. This is one example of the broader problem examined in our post, When the HOA Regulator Fails to Regulate (coming soon).


!! We are not attorneys and any written or electronic communications is provided here and/or this site as a service to the internet community. Any advice that is provided on this site is based on our experience. Consult an attorney for legal advice.

bottom of page